“Wounds and scars are not exclusive to the nobodies. Kings bear them too, as King of Scars already suggests” I wrote in my last review of Leigh Bardugo's Grishaverse.
“The monster is me and I am the monster.”
The dashing young Nikolai Lantsov is the new king of Ravka. The King of Scars is his nickname. No one knows what he endured in his country's bloody civil war—and he intends to keep it that way. Now, as enemies gather at his weakened borders, he must find a way to refill the kingdom's coffers, forge new alliances, and stop a rising threat to the once-great Grisha Army.
Yet with every day a dark magic within him grows stronger, threatening to destroy all he has built. To vanquish his inner demons, he will undertake a journey through the realm to where the deepest magic survives—and risk everything to save Ravka and himself. But some secrets aren't meant to stay buried—and some wounds aren't meant to heal.
The Too-Clever Fox
Nikolai has always had a gift for the impossible. And now the real hope of his divided people lies with him. Charismatic and visionary, he has constantly tailored his identity depending on circumstances: sometimes a rebel prince, a privateer, a war hero, an inventor, or a political strategist. While some see him as nothing more than an opportunist and an illegitimate bastard, his enemies regard him as a ‘too-clever fox’.
His will had been enough to shape not only his fate but his own identity. He had chosen what he wanted people to see—the obedient son, the feckless rogue, the able soldier, the confident politician. The monster threatened all of that.
He has also designed much of Ravka’s military hardware (aircraft, flying ships, submarines...), which the Materialki bring to life in the secret underground bases he has built on the outskirts of Ravka's capital, Os Alta. His past experience as a privateer, roaming the seas, gave him a keen understanding of the realities of the world around him and the balance of power at play, helping to make him a legitimate and respected leader.
To them, Nikolai Lantsov was not just a king or a war hero. He was the man who had restored order after the chaos of the civil war, who had granted them years of peace, who had promised them prosperity and worked to see it done.
However, power is not his main incentive; rather, it is his love of justice and of his fellow man. And given that his peers—both the nobility and the upstarts—are completely out of touch and couldn’t care less, somebody has got to try to keep the nation afloat. Even if it means sacrificing his reputation, his freedom, his feelings, his life and, ultimately, his title.
In this respect, Ravka’s King of scars is not unlike another 'scarred' figure—albeit different in every way, yet a king in his own right. I am referring to the most famous thief in Ketterdam: Kaz Brekker. His charisma, cynicism, sharp wit, courage and unwavering loyalty to his own people could only make him a perfect ally for a ruler with unorthodox methods—but ultimately honourable aims.
“I have a conscience,” said Kaz. “It just knows when to keep its mouth shut.”
“I have a surplus of bad ideas,” said Nikolai. “I have to spend them somewhere.”
When Fear Justifies the Means
But Nikolai is not the only one seeking new weapons to defend his country. His neighbours are prepared to go far beyond designing war machines and to outdo one another in cruelty in order to gain a strategic advantage. Now, they're even turning human bodies into weapons.
This is what Nina, a former member of the Crows and a Ravkan spy, and Tamar, head of Nikolai’s intelligence services, discover to their horror in secret laboratories: Nina in Fjerda, Tamar in Shu Han.
I won't give any details here that might spoil the plot, but without getting into conspiracy theories, one could nevertheless draw a parallel with certain Nazi experiments during World War II—and beyond.
“Tell me, Brekker, do you believe in monsters?”
“Of all kinds.”
Most people consider Grishas to be monsters, unnatural abominations, because their deep-seated fear of difference makes them see everything as a potential weapon that could be turned against them, rather than as something that could be used to their own advantage. And this fear, which fuels a fierce and blind hatred of the Grishas, turns those who harbour it into far greater monsters than the supposed monsters whose only crime is to exist.
War can make it hard to remember who you are. Let’s not forget the human parts of ourselves.
From Image to Mirage
But what really defines a person? Their appearance, their name, their history, their actions? In a world where bodies can be turned into weapons and where fear can lead to the dehumanisation of those we consider to be different, identity also becomes a significant issue. While some choose to reshape their appearance to suit their own ends, others are forced to adopt an identity that is not their own.
Nikolai has his features altered by Grishas so that he can pass himself off as a privateer. And when he resumes his royal duties, others must step in to keep his legendary persona alive. His role as sovereign is even briefly filled by a soldier from his guard when he disappears on his quest.
Nina also uses ‘tailoring’ to maintain her cover. In her case, it is actually a matter of life and death. Others, too, impersonate political figures, most often out of necessity or to serve a cause greater than themselves—rarely to satisfy personal ambition.
And sometimes, these protective masks lead to... irreparable collateral damage.
If Genya could make her someone new on the outside, maybe Nina’s heart would oblige and beat with a new rhythm too. Of course, it hadn’t worked.
Because altering the form does not change the substance in any way. Changing the container does not affect the contents. Except in cases of forced cohabitation, such as Nikolai's with his monster. But he is not the only one.
Most of us can hide our greatest hurts and longings. It’s how we survive each day. We pretend the pain isn’t there, that we are made of scars instead of wounds.
Ultimately, what defines us is how we choose to see others, and how we dehumanise them to make their suffering acceptable.
The girls in this wagon were not powerful witches raining down destruction. These were not faceless enemy soldiers. They were Fjerdan girls plucked from their lives and tortured. If ordinary people could not see the difference, there was no hope for anyone.
The Suli Never Forget Their Own, Just Like Crows
These are timeless and universal themes that should resonate with many readers, but which, on their own, are not enough to make us forget the shortcomings of this latest instalment in the Grishaverse.
First of all, the two main storylines (three in the second book) take far too long to get going, instead of plunging straight into the action and filling in the stakes and motivations along the way. This is particularly frustrating when the reader is already familiar with both the world and the characters. On top of that, the interweaving of these different plotlines and the multiplication of points of view significantly affect the narrative's pace and flow, occasionally disrupting the dramatic tension.
Also, some storylines, whilst promising, are not sufficiently developed (or are simply abandoned along the way, such as the one involving Matthias's wolf), in favour of others that are given too much attention—romantasy being what it is.
Nina’s emotional change of heart (no spoilers here) is rather unconvincing. Zoya’s, on the other hand, is entirely compelling. She pulls it off brilliantly and wins the day, so to speak, both in the story and in the readers’ hearts. It's a remarkable turnaround for a character who was once a relatively minor figure in the wider Grishaverse (Alina’s rival), playing the bitch in the Darkling's service before eventually siding with his opponents.
Divinely beautiful yet inaccessible, powerful yet cold as ice, she proves to be the game-changer and a genuine trump card. Though not totally out of the blue. In some respects, she reminds me of a certain Tehanu in Ursula Le Guin’s Earthsea cycle.
Finally, the brief cameos by characters from earlier books are rather disappointing overall, with the exception of Kaz Brekker who remains true to himself and his allies. In any case, the novel's closing lines strongly suggest that he and Nikolai will meet again very soon for a new mission.
Perhaps in A Darker Shore: Letters from Ketterdam, the new illustrated story added to the Six of Crows series, which I haven't read yet? Or perhaps in an entirely new series, either in the pipeline or still in the planning stages? I’m not sure yet whether it’s a good or a bad idea, but I wouldn’t say no to another adventure featuring the Fox and the Crows, as long as it isn't one of La Fontaine's fables.
© La Pensine Mutine. All rights reserved. Reproduction prohibited.

FR















